Tuesday, January 5, 2010

France to ban "psychological violence" in marriage and cohabitation


Here's a novel idea from France: The legislature is implementing a new law that would make "psychological violence" -- i.e. verbal abuse -- criminally prosecutable.  Here's the story from the UK's Daily Mail (emphasis added):
France to introduce new law banning 'psychological abuse' in marriages

France will become the first country in the world to ban 'psychological violence' within marriage later this year.

The new law, which would also apply to co-habiting couples, would see people getting criminal records for insulting their loved ones during domestic arguments.

Electronic tagging would be used on repeat offenders, according to the country's prime minister, Francois Fillon, who announced the law.

If it proves successful, it could be introduced in other European countries including Britain.

But critics dismissed the measure as a 'gimmick' which would be impossible to implement.

The law is particularly aimed at protecting women who currently suffer the worst attacks of this kind, ranging from off-hand comments about their appearance to threats of physical violence.

Mr Fillon said: 'It's an important step forward as the creation of this offence will allow us to deal with the most insidious situations - situations that leave no visible scars, but which leave victims torn up inside.'

He added that his government would also be experimenting with electronic surveillance measures to 'monitor the effectiveness of restraining orders against a violent spouse'.

Psychologist Anne Giraud said: 'Squabbling couples will allege all kinds of things about each other, but they won't necessarily be true.

'The police are likely to be called out more and more when this law comes into force this year, but often it will be a case of one person's word against the other.

'Psychological violence is a very serious matter, but punishing it through the courts is a very different matter altogether.'

Critics have also said the government should not be intervening in private domestic arguments in which no one got hurt.

Sociologist Pierre Bonnet said: 'The next step will be to make rudeness a criminal offence. The police and courts will be over-stretched trying to deal with the numerous cases.'
...

A spokesman for Mr Fillon said the new law was supported by the government, and was likely to come into effect within six months.
I do wonder how likely it is to prosecute, having to take one party's word against another's.  Also, what about "psychological violence" in families between parents towards children ... and children towards parents?  What about verbal abuse towards anyone?  How will that be prosecuted and monitored?

1 comments:

Wakefield Tolbert said...

Gotta be kidding me.

You have a great site and I tend to get long-winded, but I'll have to stop at this despite the rich harvest of mirth and knowledge I could get from the your other posts.

WOW.

Such is the Euro-nanny state.

This is how civilizations die.

The NAZIs have us Blitzkrieg.

The pan-European fluff of PC and Multi-Culti and other pieties gives us BITZ-Krieg. Little bits and pieces of law and edict from above that supposedly makes for a better civilization.

Of course.

BTW--good job on the blog layout.

(similar scheme and color pattern to mine)