
Last night I attended a local live viewing of Dave Ramsey's "Town Hall for Hope" broadcast. I am nowhere near an "economic whiz" nor possess any in depth understanding of economics. I have lived long enough, however, to have experienced our MSM's psychopathic fixation on tragedy, hyper exaggeration, and generating fear. I have also lived long enough to remember prior recessions in the 70s and 80s.
I was relieved to hear Dave Ramsey, host of a nationally syndicated radio talk show and author of several books on debt relief and personal finance, voice similar concerns that I have. He, too, is staggered by the constant gloom and doom reporting of the economy and the way the MSM and other financial "geniuses" harp on how bad times are.
Some of these "geniuses" have attempted to liken it to The Great Depression. Ramsey was quick to point out that the current situation isn't even close. He rattled off statistics of the Depression, as well as two other recessions from the 70s and 80s. Today's recession is still not as bad as those two.
Here's a brief comparison of the four economic challenges our nation has faced so far:
The Current Recession:
• The stock market experienced a 57% drop. (Interestingly, Ramsey pointed out that the stock marked has rebounded some 20% in the past seven weeks. It has recently risen from a low of 6400 to over 8000; but, the press isn't reporting this. Why???)The 70s Recession: The political situation was extremely rocky with the resignations of President Nixon and Vice President Agnew. This occurred during a serious energy crisis that many of my colleagues and friends (of course, the MSM, too) have somehow forgotten. In 1973-1974 we were in a serious recession. Other facts:
• Mortgage rates are at a 30-year low of 4 3/8%.
• 0% inflation (zero!)
• Unemployment: 8.5%
• No energy crisis, as was the case in the 70s
• Unemployment: 15%The 80s Recession: The nation came off the coat tails of Carter and Reagan came on the seen to deal with the economic problems of the day. There was a similar 50% drop in the stock market.
• Inflation: 10+%
• Stock market dropped some 50% (took 61 months to recover).
• Energy crisis: gas lines snaked around the block, and inflation became "stagflation": inflation in a stagnant economy.
• Inflation was over 10%Now, let's compare these recessions to The Great Depression (most figures from 1938-1940):
• Unemployment was over 10%
• Interest rate reached 17% on home mortgages
• Stock Market dropped 89%So, as you can see from the above information, today's recession pales in comparison to the two prior recessions, let alone when held up to the Depression.
• Unemployment grew to over 17%, peaking at 25% in 1933
• Bread lines .... real bread lines .... were everywhere (Ramsey quipped that today's executives flying to D.C. in Gulfstreams looking for bailouts hardly compare.)
Here's a little reality check on those home foreclosures: 60% of those were in 5 states (CA, AZ, FL, MI ... and missed the 5th one. Sorry!) There are 35 counties involved. Compare that to the remaining 40% of foreclosures spread out among the other 45 states.
Here are some issues the audience brought up that Ramsey addressed:
• Gold: he called this the "snuggie of investment." He really poo-pooed this as an investment strategy. According to Ramsey, gold is very volatile and, contrary to what you hear the gold ads that are everywhere, has not been used as a standard in failed economies since the days of the Romans. He gave New Orleans/Hurricane Katrina as an example: goods and services and bartering were used in that "failed economy" setting. No one was running around with little bags of gold. From 1833 to 2001, the compound annual growth rate was 1.54% -- not much return for your investment.Ramsey ended the evening with recommending that the public not buy into the fear being generated by the press. Instead, he invited people to follow his three steps: 1) get up and take action; 2) don't participate in "loser talk", and 3) start giving. Please go to Dave Ramsey's site for tons of information and advice: Town Hall for Hope.
• A good time to start up a new business? He said it very well could be. He listed several highly successful companies, still performing well, that were started up by individuals in the 70s and 80s recessions: MicroSoft, Hobby Lobby, Dell, the Weedeater was invented and was super successful. In 1946, the Chick-fil-a company was started.
• Will we become a "cashless society?" Will the dollar be replaced as the world standard? Ramsey really doubted this and chalked such fears up to the "gloom & doom folks."
• Unemployment: Ramsey emphasized that jobs going down is a symptom of the economy slowing down. Making up jobs won't fix it. As the economy corrects, jobs will go up.
• FDR ended The Depression? Ramsey went back to the history of the day -- something that today's financial "geniuses" fail to factor in. Ramsey asserted that FDR had adopted the economic strategy of John Maynard Keynes (pronounced "Canes") of England -- "The Father of Deficit Spending." However, it wasn't Keynesian economic theory that saved the U.S., but rather World War II. That historic event is what dropped the country's unemployment rate down to 1% brought on by the astronomical demand for goods. Ramsey pointed out that Milton Friedman, who won the Nobel Prize for economics in 1976 for his theories on capitalism and free markets, thus shooting down Keynes' theories.
2 comments:
Ramsey is great. I heard about the event and knew it would be great. A calm voice in the midst of hysteria is usually the one to follow. Thanks for the post.
WJP
I think Ramsey is quite good at what he does best, and that's training and counseling individuals to live within their means ... and that means, "free of debt." Indeed, we are 10 weeks into his 13-week Financial Peace University at our church. We have done Dave's approach to things about 70% of the way until now — now we're trying to seal the deal and take it all the way: no credit cards, month budgets on paper, saving like fiends, etc.
Unfortunately, Dave he falls flat when he bad-mouths precious metals as "stupid." His mantra that "metals are never used in the barter economies that follow disasters" is a straw man argument (though somewhat understandable, given that some metal and coin dealers seem to imply that metals will be money when the feces hits the fan).
Precious metals shouldn't be bought/held for a TEOTWAWKI scenario, but as an historically-reliable store of value.
A couple of ignorant things I've heard Dave say recently about precious metals:
• "They have no more intrinsic value than a shoelace." (IOW, precious metals only have value because man assigns it value and does so arbitrarily — we could just as easily assign similar value to dirt!) I'm utterly amazed that Dave doesn't grasp fundamental principles of value found in precious metals such as world-wide recognizability and desirability, ease of divisibility and transportability, and high value in relation to volume and weight.
• "PMs haven't been a medium of exchange since the Roman empire." This is simple ignorance of history. What does Dave think the value of US currency was pegged to by law until only 1971? (Not to mention that silver has been a component element of US coins until 1964!)
It is a paradox that, while preaching so faithfully against personal indebtedness, Dave won't/can't preach against government indebtedness and the central-bank-issued fiat currency that aids and abets it. I know Dave is a Bible-believing Christian — well, the Bible vehemently condemns theft by the use of unjust weights and measures, which is precisely what fiat currency is: "faith-based" money that is backed up by absolutely nothing and which results in that most insidious a invisible of taxes, a.k.a. inflation.(Oh, incidentally, Dave defined "inflation" at the Town Hall for Hope as "price increases due to variables of supply and demand." Yes, prices do fluctuate as a result of supply and demand, but inflation is an increase in the amount of money in circulation at the hands of central banks and government-owned printing presses. When more money is pumped into the system via the printing press or electronic credits, it serves to devalue the money already in circulation, and prices rise in response to that. IOW, long-term price increases are not inflation, but rather they are a symptom of inflation — more money chasing after a fixed amount of goods. The best example I can point to is the artificial boom in home values earlier this decade, which were the direct result of the ease with which more and more people were able to get loans. I.e., more money — in the form of credit — chasing after a fixed supply of houses.)
For a different — and reliable — take on our current economic mess, I would urge you to spend some time reading the articles and watching the videos of Peter Schiff. Just Google him ... you'll find him. Peter is also "death on debt" — but he called the current financial mess a few years ago, based on the fact that Americans and their government borrow endlessly to buy things they simply cannot afford. I.e., rampant consumerism and endless lines of credit.
I love Dave for what he does well, but he has a ways to go to understand the government-monetary-policy basis for the dire straits in which our nation currently finds itself.
Post a Comment